The Appeal to Authority Fallacy and Gizmo's Chickens

Gizmo was so preoccupied with whether or not he could, he didn't stop to think if he should.

Gizmo tries to use science as a shield, to silence anyone that questions his horrible experiment. 

Find out how Gizmo rules the roost with our fun Trust the Experts (Appeal to Authority Activity Pack)!

Appeal to Authority in a Nutshell

Gizmo didn't answer Bruno's concern. He dissolved it. "If you're questioning me, you are questioning Science itself" isn't a defence of the experiment - it's a way of making questions feel forbidden.

That's the Appeal to Authority. Instead of explaining why the Super Chicken Project is sound, Gizmo invokes an unquestionable force - Science, Experts, Consensus - and implies that anyone who pushes back is either ignorant or arrogant. The argument stops being about evidence and starts being about who has the right to speak.

The thing is, experts can be wrong. Science is a process, not a person - and it works precisely because people are allowed to question it. Gizmo's real mistake wasn't injecting the chickens. It was deciding that authority was a substitute for a good argument. The chickens had thoughts about this.

See all 24 fallacies in What Are the Most Common Logical Fallacies?

If you would like to receive our weekly comics, plus regular fun freebies, updates and more, sign up to our weekly newsletter. Scroll down to subscribe.