The cleverer you think you are, the easier you are to fool.
The cards you see here are already available - 24 fallacies you can print and play tonight, straight from our Etsy shop. Now we're turning that deck into something better: a brand-new, beautifully boxed edition of What's That Fallacy?, with sharper cards and better gameplay. Grab the print-and-play version today, or get first dibs on the new game below.
Same sharp game. Now new, improved and gift-ready.
We took everything players loved about the original print-and-play deck and made it better: rewritten cards, fresh illustrations, and a sturdy keepsake box that looks as good on the shelf as it plays at the table. Built to be unwrapped, re-played, and handed around for years.
- ✓ Premium linen-finish cards that survive family game night
- ✓ A giftable box - no printing, no cutting, ready to play
- ✓ All 24 fallacies, illustrated with Duchess & Bruno
- ✓ Quick-start rules anyone gets in thirty seconds
24 Fallacies & the Historical Disasters that Followed
Launching at the same time as the card game: the book that shows what happens when nobody spots the fallacy in time. Each chapter pairs one fallacy with a true history disaster - from witch trials to wars - so you don't just learn the trick, you see the wreckage it leaves behind.
Play the game to catch fallacies at the dinner table. Read the book to understand why catching them matters.
Thirty seconds to learn. Years of being unbearable at dinner.
Draw a card — and keep it secret
One player is the Describer. They draw a fallacy card from the deck and don't show it to anyone else.
Commit the crime — without saying the name
The Describer invents a scenario that illustrates the fallacy. Everyone else races to guess which one it is.
Score points — first to 10 wins
Correct guessers and the Describer each earn a point. First player to reach 10 takes the glory.
First to 10 wins!
Correct guessers and the Describer bank a point every round. Race to ten, then wear the "Most Insufferably Logical" crown with pride.
From family dinners to classrooms
Nobody can stop calling each other out - in the best possible way.
"Really clever and funny comics. I wasn't expecting them to be so funny. My husband and kids really like them. We've placed the cards on the kitchen table to practice whenever we get a chance after dinner and they're a lot of fun! It takes a bit of practice but over time it sticks. Cute pics too."
"These cards are amazing and so much fun. My family loves them, we're now catching ourselves using the fallacies which I didn't think would happen. That's such a bonus. Thank you for including the black and white copies, as my kids really enjoyed colouring them too. A 10/10 resource!"
★★★★★ 5.0 from 2 reviews · 100% of buyers recommend it
You've seen a taste - now claim the game & book first.
The all-new card game and the book land together in a few months. Join the waitlist and we'll tell you the second they exist - plus you'll get an early-bird launch discount before anyone else.